Customer Ratings & Reviews

This eyeliner, especially the black is so pigmented that with one flick your whole eye can be done. Sometimes you do have to go over it once or twice because the brush doesn't soak up the product but overall its a really nice eyeliner for the price. The sparkle ones are also beautifully pigmented but you have to reapply a few times since only a few sparkles stick on the bristle when it comes out of the tube. So if you want the sparkles more visible just stroke some more on. Elf has recently been stocked here in Australian kmart stores so i hope some more aussies get into the brand.

I purchased this 3 piece set basically for the black liquid eyeliner which is probably one of the best liquid liners in the market as it is so easy to use; the other two liners were basically a bonus buy; that was the way I justified the purchase =) I do like the glitter liners for use at night and to give an eye look that extra bit of sparkle. I would repurchase again and add as an extra gift if I was purchasing makeup/makeup basket for a family member or friend.

Very cheap but also effective. Black eye liner rocks. Intense colour, full black the shape of the brush is amazing, helps a lot in order to draw the line in your eye. The other 2 are not "writing" in the eye. 4 stars only for the fact that usable is only the black colour

Eyeliners dry late, this one doesn't dry as late as the ones from other brands I've tried. As I thought the glitter stuff didnt really show and ended up more in the lashes than on the eyelid. Gave those to my 13 yo niese and she finds them fab (but what else would you think someone who has barely lived would say to glitter make up?).

I was seeking out a vegan black liquid eyeliner and decided to try E.L.F. I'm very happy about the applicator brush, it's perfect and very easy to use. I dislike felt and pen-like applicators. Unfortunately the consistency isn't great, it's pretty watery and needs a couple applications/layers to become opaque. It stays well. I'd recommend using a primer on your lids first.

Great product. Elf makes quality makeup products with affordable prices. Surely will order again, and check out their other products too. Selling cruelty-free cosmetics. Peta approves! Who wouldn't love this company?

These are awesome! I'd never used liquid eyeliner before but these are so easy to use and I love layering the sparkles over the black, especially the gold one.

Cute; easy to apply and bold sparkles. The only draw backs are that the sparkles did fall into my eye and irritate it but that only happened once.

The liquid is good and stays on entire day. But the brush should be improved, it is stinging when you try to apply near the corners of the eye.

i actually bought this set for the glitter liners because i love sparkly things. i really don't like them - they take quite a while to dry, can sting the eyes and then flake off after a short time. i was very pleasantly surprised by the black. it's a fantastic cheap liquid liner and lasts all day and night.