Posted by LouPou83 on Nov 26, 2013
i liked only black color
ELF eyeliner set
Posted by 4763021770363552511 on May 23, 2014
Normal use ok.
Posted by 5089689560867271805 on Aug 21, 2014
All but the black were dried out!
Posted by 4979512643801212867 on Oct 17, 2014
i can't use the black one at all, it just slides off when trying to apply and when dries looks clumpy and ugly. the glitter-ones are very subtle and nice though.
NOT LONG LASTING
Posted by 5464899303733060609 on Oct 19, 2014
I have oily eye lids so I want products that not smudge easily, the black one out of the tree transfers up on my eye lid in less than an hour. It was a disappointment for me since I bought them for the black one. I do not have a strong opinion about the other two glittery ones since I never used them.