Better than most! But possible unethical and contains a nasty paraben..
Posted by Susamedusa on Jun 13, 2012
Just resently discovered the sharpener at the bottom, so now I'm happier with this product. Compared to mac eye pencil (I've never been so dissatisfied with a product before - totally don't get the hype of mac products) this is heaven! I will recommend to all my friends if I can figure out that it's not tested on animals. I give it tree stars because I can't find out if it's animal tested or not, see. The product works better than any eye pencil I've ever tried these last 18 years, but I can't support animal testing (and I don't know whether it's animal-tested or not yet, even though I suppose iHerb wouldn't let in animal-tested products). I'm a bit fuzzy about parabens and this contains propylparaben, which is listed red in many Asthma and Allergy Assosiations. Shame.
Goes on smooth and even. Will buy agan.
Posted by amarrille on Feb 28, 2012
Bought it twice. I like it!
Physician's Formula Eye definer
Posted by uppsala on Jun 05, 2015
Although the name says that it's a midnight black, it's more grey, than black. It smudges easily, and if I put it in the morning, it's gone till noon. The good side is that it has sharpener on it. I hoped that I had found cheaper replacement for my expensive eye liner, but unfortunatelly it's not the case.
Posted by Xhalax on Nov 24, 2016
I really love this eye liner and use it all the time. It's quite soft, easy to apply, has good pigmentation, doesn't feather and stays on well. It's easy to sharpen as well. I have this in both black and brown and they are equally good.
Posted by 4729313575326320355 on Apr 20, 2015
This is very Excellent iHerb services
Great eye pencil
Posted by Reviewer1034718 on Mar 30, 2012
I like it. It's really soft and remains on my eyes all day long... No discomfort, no dirty traces...
Posted by misstessie on Aug 29, 2013
Dark black, goes on smooth without tugging at the skin, can be smudged for a smokey look. Really good.
Automatic eye pencil
Posted by 5624357582150766350 on Dec 03, 2013
Nice Eye pencil... Thanks Iherb for shipping these to France!
Can't believe the quality for the price.
Posted by 4971078063139849194 on Dec 26, 2013