I bought this eyeliner without great expectations, as I had never tried the product before and I know that ELF is a fairly cheap product. I was disappointed in the "waterproof-ness" of this product. To be blunt, it isn't. At all. Despite the obvious false marketing, I actually really like it, it has great colour pay-off a true black. It lasts decently,l like I said it isn't waterproof but it is smudge-proof, doesn't transfer onto my lower lash line at all throughout the day. I really like the packaging, very sturdy considering the price and I love the application. Though I have the feeling the felt tip applicator will dry up fairly quickly, but this is yet to be proven. With all this in mind I am genuinely quite impressed and would definitely recommend!
Posted by iHerb Customer on Mar 31, 2015 | Verified Purchase
Worked well while it lasted, which wasn't long at all. Dried up very quickly.
Posted by iHerb Customer on Nov 17, 2014 | Verified Purchase
not what I expect it to be. brush a bit too hard
Posted by iHerb Customer on Oct 30, 2014 | Verified Purchase
I've used many ELF-products with joy, but this was a disappointment. It didn't last long, and dried pretty quickly. The brush was good though.
Posted by iHerb Customer on Oct 27, 2014 | Verified Purchase
I had great expectations for this, even if it was a low budget eyeliner. It did, however, not satisfy. It's not very waterproofy, it was half-dry when it arrived, and it was hard and uncomfortable to apply. It is, despite the critisism, an ok product. It stays on for a fair amount of time. But don't expect too much.
Posted by MasksOffMasksOn on Oct 26, 2014 | Verified Purchase
I got it because I needed a waterproof liwuid liner, but this is really not a waterproof one- not at all! Such a shame... And the black is not so black either :/
Posted by iHerb Customer on Jul 21, 2014 | Verified Purchase
This was the first time I ever used an eyeliner. Sorry to say that I'm disappointed. The color is dull and difficult to apply. When I tried harder it was painful. Couldn't make a fine and steady line. I gave it 2 stars only because of the price. Won't buy it again.
Posted by iHerb Customer on May 27, 2014 | Verified Purchase
Had to shake the pen a bit for ink to come out - not as dark and think as i was hoping.
Posted by iHerb Customer on May 23, 2014 | Verified Purchase
Posted by iHerb Customer on May 12, 2014 | Verified Purchase
It was abit dried out wen I received it....
Posted by iHerb Customer on Oct 24, 2013 | Verified Purchase
First tried but did last long and had to reapply within an hour.
1-10 of 10 total